Dear Abbey...
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Dazzled
  • About

Liz & Leslie

7/11/2015

0 Comments

 
Pictureimage source: www.eonline.com
I recently started watching Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt on Netflix, which got me thinking about Tina Fey's other television masterpiece, 30 Rock, as well as Amy Poehler's Parks and Recreation. And I started thinking about what I have heard people say about these two shows, about Liz Lemon and Leslie Knope, and about their respective creators.

So the thing that's been bugging me lately is an article I read the other day that claimed that these two shows are unfairly grouped together merely because they both feature female leads, despite the fact that the shows are so different (Parks and Rec being a much more optimistic, heartfelt show; 30 Rock being more cynical and farcical). I have also heard criticism that Leslie Knope is a better female lead than Liz Lemon, because while Leslie Knope is perky and enthusiastic, Liz Lemon comes off as pathetic, and obsessive over the ideal of "having it all."

However, I'm not sure if I agree with either of these criticisms. Before I start, let me just say that I have watched and enjoyed both shows. I also strongly identify with both Liz and Leslie, and have been repeatedly compared to both Leslie Knope and Liz Lemon (as well as Amy Poehler and Tina Fey).

Okay, so the thing about 30 Rock and Parks and Recreation is that they can and should be grouped together. Not just because both are NBC shows. Not because their respective creators hosted the Golden Globes together. Not because they did Weekend Update, Baby Mama, and Mean Girls together. Not because both feature female leads. But because they compliment each other exceptionally well.

Liz Lemon and Leslie Knope are yin and yang: complete opposites, but nevertheless equals. Leslie Knope comes off as more empowering, reflecting on the oft-embraced ideal by feminists that women are capable of anything. However, the problem with this is that Leslie lives in Pawnee, Indiana, fictional not only in name but also in its heartfelt, goofy, optimistic mood. While Leslie Knope's optimistic, enthusiastic humor is definitely appealing, this does not in any way make Liz Lemon inferior. Liz Lemon represents the other end of the spectrum for the modern feminist: she is very flawed, and the sense of humor around her character is one that is self-deprecating rather than kindhearted and enthusiastic. She is judgmental. She calls her writing staff "dummies." She is stubborn and sarcastic.

The point I guess I'm trying to make is this: both are great feminist characters because both are intelligent women who love their work. They do their own thing, and both are incredible in that they develop platonic male-female friendships (and while some may argue that Jack and Liz have a relationship that is less equal than that of Leslie and Ron, it should be noted that often times Liz ignores Jack's advice, or he calls on her for help).

I feel like Liz Lemon and Leslie Knope represent two "selves" of modern feminists (at least the ones that are straight, white, and cisgender): Leslie Knope is that part of yourself that encourages you to do anything. She is the voice inside your head that tells you anything is possible: that gay penguins can get married, that pits can become parks, and that all female politicians (regardless of political party) can be equally respected. She is the part of yourself that you aspire to be all the time. She is ambitious, happy, and ignores limitations. Liz Lemon is the most flawed part of yourself. She is the version of yourself that is sometimes accepting of failure (like being willing to get a cat named Emily Dickinson when resigning herself/yourself to spinsterhood). She is harshly judgmental, even discovering to have been a sarcastic bully in high school. She is dishonest at times. She is the voice inside your head telling you that, if all else fails, don a Snuggie and work on your night cheese. While Leslie Knope is what many feminists aspire to be, Liz Lemon allows women to embrace their flaws and failures, rather than thinking poorly of themselves when their aspirations fall short.

In short, the shows are different, yes, but deserve to be grouped together. Leslie Knope is not a better feminist role model than Liz Lemon, nor is Liz Lemon a better role model than Leslie Knope. It's important to recognize that both women can be seen as fictional feminist role models. Together, they embody a 21st century feminism that is ambitious and yet flawed. A feminism that loves food (perhaps too much) but doesn't care. That recognizes the value of platonic male friends. That is nice to everyone and yet still judgmental. That both gracefully admits to not understanding youth culture, and exclaims, "oh God, youths!" when seeing teenagers pass by on the street. That recognizes both Galentine's Day and Anna Howard Shaw Day.

And one that recognizes the strides women have made in both politics and television.

Picture
image sources: society6.com
~Abbey xoxo
Picture
0 Comments

    Author

    Abbey...
    High School student.
    Feminist.
    Book Nerd.
    Movie Lover.
    Thespian.

    Archives

    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    Categories

    All
    1940s
    1960s
    2015
    30 Rock
    Adolescence
    Amy Poehler
    Andy Botwin
    Angela Chase
    Anne Frank
    Annie Hall
    AP
    Art
    Awareness
    Beauty
    Beauty Standards
    Beckie0
    Beyonce
    Bikini Kill
    Blogilates
    Body Focused Repetitive Behavior
    Books
    Bottle Rocket
    Calculus
    Carrie Hope Fletcher
    Catcalling
    Catholic Church
    Celebrities
    Charli XCX
    College
    Compliments
    Confidence
    Conformity
    Constrained Writing
    Cramps
    Creativity
    Crushes
    Daria
    David Sedaris
    Dazzled
    Diary
    Disorders
    Doctor Who
    Drama Club
    Driving
    Driving Lessons
    Email
    Emma Simons-Araya
    Existential Crisis
    Eyebrows
    Eyeliner
    Fandoms
    Fangirl
    Fantastic Mr. Fox
    Fashion
    Female Empowerment
    Feminism
    Fiction
    Film
    Freaks And Geeks
    Friends
    Games
    Gender Equality
    Gender Roles
    Gestalt
    Ghost World
    God
    Hair
    Harry Potter
    Heartbreak
    History
    Humanity
    Identity
    Individuality
    Inferiority
    Internet
    Janeane Garofalo
    Jane McGonigal
    Jenji Kohan
    Jersey Shore
    Jill Sobule
    John Oliver
    Judaism
    Julia Sweeney
    Kathleen Hanna
    Laci Green
    Lana Del Rey
    Lesley Gore
    Leslie Knope
    Life
    Lipogram
    Liz Lemon
    Make-unders
    Makeup
    Malvina Reynolds
    Math
    Max Fischer
    Mental Health
    Michael Shermer
    Miss Literati
    Moonrise Kingdom
    Music
    My So-Called Life
    N+7
    Nancy Botwin
    Netflix
    Nostalgia
    Nuclear Physics
    Objectification
    Open Letter
    Orange Is The New Black
    Parks And Recreation
    Playlist
    Poetry
    Pop Culture
    Protest Songs
    Psychology
    Punk Rock
    Rachael Ray
    Realistic Fiction
    Relationships
    Religion
    Riot Grrrl
    Rolling Stones
    Rookie
    Ruby Wax
    Rushmore
    Satire
    Seneca Falls Convention
    Senior Year
    Sex+
    Sexism
    Sexual Harassment
    Sexuality
    Sherlock
    Snooki
    Squaresville
    Stage Management
    Stephen Colbert
    Stereotypes
    Stevie Nicks
    Sucker
    Supervenus
    Tavi Gevinson
    TED Talks
    Television
    The Darjeeling Limited
    The Grand Budapest Hotel
    The Great Gatsby
    The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou
    The Lizzie Bennet Diaries
    The Royal Tenenbaums
    Tina Fey
    To-do List
    Trichotillomania
    Tumblr
    Twitter
    Uncertainty
    Unitarianism
    Univocalic
    Unrequited Love
    Vietnam War
    Vi Hart
    Weeds
    Wes Anderson
    Winged Eyeliner
    Woman Suffrage
    Women
    Woody Allen
    Writer's Block
    Writing
    WWII
    Yoga
    YouTube

    RSS Feed

Powered by
✕